Namd on BGQ

A parameter study was undertaken to test simulation performance and efficiency of NAMD on the Blue Gene/Q cluster with attention to NAMD performance tuning documentation. The system of study is a 246,000 atom membrane protein simulation (Cytochrome c Oxidase embedded in a TIP3P solvated DPPC bilayer) using the CHARMM36 forcefield (protein and lipids). The unit cell is cubic with box dimensions 144 x 144 x 117 Angstroms.

Performance Tuning Benchmarks

Efficiency us measured with respect to the 16 ranks-per-node 512 core simulation. All simulations are started from a pre-equilibrated snapshots restart file. Performance in nanoseconds per day is based on the geometric mean of the three Benchmark time lines at the beginning of the simulation's standard output and any additional configuration options are listed where they are used.

Ranks	Cores	NAMD Config Options	ns/day	Efficiency
16	512		2.79	1.00
16	1024		5.05	0.91
16	1024	twoAwayX (default)	5.62	1.01
16	2048	twoAwayX (default)	10.07	0.90
16	2048	twoAwayXY	10.59	0.95
16	4096	twoAwayX	14.32	0.64
16	4096	twoAwayXY (default)	17.63	0.79
16	4096	twoAwayXYZ	16.79	0.75
16	8192	twoAwayX	23.52	0.53
16	8192	twoAwayXY (default)	25.00	0.56
16	16384	twoAwayX	23.67	0.27
16	16384	twoAwayXY	28.31	0.32
16	16384	twoAwayXYZ (default)	27.98	0.31
16	4096	twoAwayXY, PMEPencils=8, lblUnload=yes	12.93	0.58
16	4096	twoAwayXY, PMEPencils=12, lblUnload=yes	17.27	0.77
16	4096	twoAwayXY, PMEPencils=16, lblUnload=yes	16.02	0.72
16	4096	twoAwayXY, PMEPencils=20, lblUnload=yes	15.41	0.69
16	4096	twoAwayXY, PMEPencils=12	16.21	0.73
16	4096	twoAwayXY, PMEPencils=16	17.92	0.80
16	4096	twoAwayXY, PMEPencils=20	17.99	0.81
16	4096	twoAwayXY, PMEPencils=24	17.83	0.80
16	4096	twoAwayXY, PMEPencils=36	16.97	0.76
8	4096	twoAwayXY, PMEPencils=20	18.24	0.82
16	4096	twoAwayXY, PMEPencils=20	17.99	0.81
32	4096	twoAwayXY, PMEPencils=20	13.94	0.63
4	512		2.86	1.03
8	512		2.84	1.02
16	512		2.79	1.00
32	512		2.29	0.82
16	512	ldbUnloadZero=yes	2.79	1.00

Incorrect Particle-Mesh Ewald Grid

Long-range electrostatics are computed using PME for all simulations with PME grid spacing set to be generated automatically with the pmeGridSpacing 1.0 setting. A poor choice in PME grid spacing (i.e. not a multiple of 2,3, and 5) can result in increasingly large performance degradation.

Ranks	Cores	NAMD Config Options	ns/day	Efficiency
16	512	Poor PME Multiple (144x144x111)	2.70	0.97
16	1024	Poor PME Multiple (144x144x111)	5.13	0.92
16	2048	Poor PME Multiple (144x144x111)	8.61	0.77
16	4096	Poor PME Multiple (144x144x111)	13.93	0.62
16	8192	Poor PME Multiple (144x144x111)	17.08	0.38
16	16384	Poor PME Multiple (144x144x111)	17.64	0.20

Documentation

1. NAMD 2.9 User Guide
2. NAMD Performance Tuning Wiki